This is fairly good minimalistic music. It reminds me of what I might hear if Phillip Glass or Steve Reich started using midi files to compose. I think the choice of bass drum really helped to cover the attack flaws of the guitar sample. Well done.
While this may not be my normal style of music, I can definitely appreciate that it works well for its purpose. It makes me want to get up and dance.
This is a very good start. While the basic outline you have created can act as a backdrop for these scenes, if you would like to truly portray the story in your music, I would recommend adding to your composition. For example, a battle is supposed to be taking place, yet I did not hear a single gunshot in your music; there is supposed to be shouting and chaos at points, however the music remained soft in dynamic and relatively smooth in character; also, I could not hear a difference between the various environments that the crew was supposed to be placed in. Essentially, while you captured the moods quite well overall, I do not think that you painted a clear picture with your music. This would be like looking through wax paper at a landscape and having to require someone to tell you that there is a tree five feet in front of you: you may know you are in a relaxing, beautiful environment, but you know nothing about it.
Hey man first off I want to say thanks for the actual review, it's nice to see a different opinion than previous.
I agree with you completely, if I truly wanted to make an audio representation of what was happening, I'd definitely add many of the things you stated there, such as sound effects and all but unfortunately most of the songs I make are made in a day or two, in my spare time (not that that's an excuse for quality).
You are right however, there's no way of knowing the story whatsoever without my explanation below. Thanks again for your input
newgrounds.com — Your #1 online entertainment & artist community! All your base are belong to us.